Cavaliers still seeking first win as they fall to Generals, 17-6
Hollis Brookline's Gabe McGrath (55) tries to tackle John Stark's Cooper Twombly (7) during Saturday's Division III game in Hollis. (Photo by Dan Attorri)
HOLLIS – The Hollis-Brookline football team has faced its share of adversity in the last couple of seasons, but for head coach Patrick Gendron, it’s all about how his players respond.
The Cavaliers allowed John Stark to score on the opening kickoff of Saturday’s homecoming game and Hollis-Brookline responded with its best defensive performance of the season. But the Cavs couldn’t muster enough offense to stick with the Generals as Hollis-Brookline fell to John Stark, 17-6.
“We weren’t as prepared as we needed to be,” Gendon said. “John Stark came out and was the better team today.”
The Generals (2-3) won their first game since their Week 1 come-from-behind victory over Trinity and came out of the gate quickly, with junior Ethan Byers breaking a tackle and breaking away for an 85-yard yard return on the opening kick.
Senior Stevin Niebel scored on a 10-yard quarterback keeper, but the kick was driven into the linemen, allowing John Stark to hold a 7-6 lead with 5:04 left in the second quarter.
Both Niebel (2-for-8, 19 passing yards) and junior AJ Scott (3-for-14, 12 passing yards) took snaps at quarterback, and Niebel was also Hollis-Brookline’s leading rusher with 57 yards on six carries, while Scott had 32 yards on 11 carries.
Senior Cole Duncan (41 yards on nine carries, two catches for 15 yards) and sophomore Nolan Barry (33 yards on 15 carries) also helped the Cavs drive to the Stark 10, 21 and 31 in the first half, but all of those drives stalled.
John Stark senior Cooper Twombly picked off Scott on the first drive of the second half and nearly returned it for a touchdown before being taken down at the 2. Twombly (56 yards on 17 carries) finished the job with a 2-yard TD on the next play to make it 14-6 at 10:36.
The Cavaliers only allowed a field goal the rest of the way (senior AJ Bellen connected on a 42 yarder with 13 seconds left in the third quarter), but struggled offensively.
An offensive highlight came late in the fourth quarter when Duncan connected with sophomore Thurston Balmer for 32 yards (the longest passing play of the game) on a trick play, helping the Cavs reach Stark territory, but the drive ended on the 26 with 3:41 left in the game.
John Stark senior quarterback Jack Sheppard (4-for-10, 17 passing yards) and Twombly did enough on the final drive to move the chains to run out the clock to secure the win.
Despite not being able to finish drives on offense, the Hollis-Brookline defense had its best performance of the season, combining for seven tackles for loss.
Sophomore Paul Lapierre (three tackles for loss), senior Gabe McGrath (sack, tackle for loss), junior Enzo Kolar (fumble recovery in the fourth quarter) and sophomore Ben York (sack) led the Cavaliers’ defense. Previously, the least points Hollis had allowed this season was 44 against Milford in a 44-13 loss on Sept. 18.
“Defense played great,” Gendron said. “The kids worked hard during the week to figure out the game plan and correct some mistakes from weeks past.”
The Cavs (0-5) have four more weeks to find the win column and will next play at ConVal (1-4) on Friday night.


